7.03.2008

either margaret wente needs a fact-checker or the entire united states is a backwater

I usually avoid reading Margaret Wente, but this morning the Globe and Mail put her on the front page, so a bit filtered through. She writes:
It's right to honour Henry Morgentaler with the Order of Canada. He fought to make this country a better place for women, and he succeeded.

But those who either lionize or despise Dr. Morgentaler tend to miss the point. By the time he came along, the tectonic plates were well in motion. Hospital abortions had already been available for years – subject to approval by a medical committee. Dr. Morgentaler's achievement was to make abortion a woman's private choice, subject to no one's approval but her own.

Except for a few backwaters in the United States, safe, legal and accessible abortion is the norm throughout the Western world. It would be the norm in this country, too, regardless of Dr. Morgentaler's pioneering work. He's a symbol now, and the passions he arouses are the same ones aroused by Roe v. Wade in the U.S.

Emphasis added. And added and added. Here are your backwaters, Ms. Wente.

  • In 2000, 87% of US counties had no abortion provider. Thirty-four percent of women aged 15-44 live in those counties. Eighty-six of the US's 276 metropolitan areas had no provider.

  • Abortions in the United States cost anywhere from $400 to $4000, depending on the procedure. A first-trimester abortion costs more than a family on public assistance receives in a month.

    Low-income women and girls often delay procedures as they try to borrow the money they need. (Not easy when most people you know live hand-to-mouth.) "Chasing the funds" - as it is known in the movement - often forces women into second-trimester procedures. Those procedures are more complicated, more risky - and much more expensive. It is not uncommon for women to carry an unwanted pregnancy to term because they cannot afford a simple first-trimester procedure.

    These three states prohibit the use of any state funds for abortion whatsoever. They have refused to comply with a federal law requiring states to provide Medicaid funding for abortion in cases of life endangerment, rape or incest.
    Alabama
    Mississippi
    South Dakota

    These states fund abortion in cases of threat to life, rape or incest only. All must be proven in court.
    Arizona
    Arkansas
    Colorado
    Delaware
    Florida
    Georgia
    Indiana
    Kansas
    Kentucky
    Louisiana
    Maine
    Michigan
    Missouri
    Nebraska
    Nevada
    North Carolina
    North Dakota
    Ohio
    Oklahoma
    Pennsylvania
    Rhode Island
    South Carolina
    Tennessee
    Texas
    Utah
    Wyoming

    These states will fund abortion where there is threat to a woman's life or health, rape, incest, and some other reasons, such as verifiable abuse or mental health issues. All require several court appearances.
    Iowa
    New Mexico
    Virginia
    Wisconsin

  • These states restrict abortion access by age, requiring mandatory parental notification or consent for minors. States are required to provide varying degrees of so-called "judicial bypass", meaning a young person can plead her case to a judge, who can then grant or deny her permission to obtain an abortion without parental notification or consent. Think about that one.
    Alabama
    Alaska
    Arizona
    Arkansas
    Colorado
    Delaware
    Florida
    Georgia
    Idaho
    Illinois
    Indiana
    Iowa
    Kansas
    Kentucky
    Louisiana
    Maine
    Maryland
    Massachusetts
    Michigan
    Minnesota
    Mississippi
    Missouri
    Nebraska
    North Carolina
    North Dakota
    Ohio
    Oklahoma
    Pennsylvania
    Rhode Island
    South Carolina
    South Dakota
    Tennessee
    Texas
    Virginia
    West Virginia
    Wisconsin
    Wyoming

    Every state not listed here has had parental consent or notification laws introduced in its legislature, which activists defeated, often by tiny margins. The mandatory judicial bypass clauses are also the result of court orders won by activism.

    Before any parents reading this trot out the old "if my daughter was having an abortion, I would want to know" response, let's just say: of course. That's obvious. And if you want to know if your daughter is having sex, or fears she is pregnant, or needs an abortion, create a home environment where your children know they can come to you with any problem, and receive unconditional support and love, even if that love includes disapproval.

    Many teens are not that fortunate. I know from first-hand experience that in a home where young people fear abuse, including one's parents in decisions about sex and pregnancy is simply not an option. For their own health and safety, girls must be able to obtain abortions without telling their parents, and no state law is going to change that.

  • These states require women seeking abortions to register, then wait 24 or 48 hours before receiving a procedure.
    Alabama
    Arkansas
    Georgia
    Idaho
    Kansas
    Kentucky
    Louisiana
    Michigan
    Minnesota
    Mississippi
    Nebraska
    North Dakota
    Ohio
    Oklahoma
    Pennsylvania
    South Carolina
    South Dakota
    Texas
    Utah
    West Virginia
    Virginia
    Wisconsin

    On first glance, a waiting period may seem innocuous. But for a low-income woman who must arrange child care and transportation, and travel a long distance to an abortion provider, the mandatory waiting period means one or more overnight stays, all of which she has to pay for - and none of which she can afford. If she is trying to terminate a pregnancy against the wishes of an abusive partner, an overnight stay can be the difference between life and death.

    State-mandated waiting periods are condescending and demeaning, as they assume women cannot think for themselves and are requesting abortions in some kind of momentary fit of non-reason.

    Only procedures relating to reproduction are subject to mandatory waiting periods. No other elective medical procedures are regulated by such laws.

  • These states prohibit private insurance coverage for abortion.
    Idaho
    Kentucky
    Missouri
    North Dakota

    These states exclude abortion coverage from state health care programs.
    Illinois
    Montana

  • These states have spousal consent or notification laws. All spousal consent/notification laws have been ruled unconstitutional, and are therefore unenforceable, but they remain state laws.
    Colorado
    Illinois
    Kentucky
    Louisiana
    North Dakota
    Pennsylvania
    Rhode Island
    South Carolina

    Like the parental consent/notification laws, many more states have had spousal/partner consent laws debated and defeated in their legislatures.

    * * * *

    Ms Wente says: "Except for a few backwaters in the United States, safe, legal and accessible abortion is the norm throughout the Western world."

    Does this seem like a "few backwaters" to you? Does it look like abortion is accessible in the United States?

    Without access, the right to abortion is meaningless.

    * * * *

    All facts in this post are verifiable at these reliable sources:
    Human Rights Watch
    The Guttmacher Institute
    Planned Parenthood Federation of America
    NARAL Pro-Choice America
    National Network of Abortion Funds
    National Coalition of Abortion Providers
    American Civil Liberties Union

    Although I didn't use it for this post, Wikipedia's entry on abortion in the United States is quite good.
  • No comments: