6.23.2025
pupdate: sad (but not that saddest) news
6.22.2025
celebrating indigenous people's day with a beautiful evening in the port hardy library
We hosted two Indigenous elders, both women, who led workshops in an art of their culture. In one, participants created mini button blankets; in the other, people learned cedar weaving technique, using paper and other materials substituting for cedar.
Why was it such a great program?
* The participants were both First Nations and settler. That, sadly, is rare. The library is one of the few places where we see the two communities interact in a positive way.
* People were relaxed and happy, chatting quietly while they sewed and wove.
* Three participants had never been to the library before, and signed up for new library cards! This is a big win!
* Everyone kept thanking us for the experience, telling us what a great night it was.
* Both these elders have been struggling with isolation and depression. They have both lost many family members in the past few years, many who were very young, from addiction and suicide. They each told me the program gave them a huge uplift, a chance to connect with people, a reminder that they are not alone. This is valuable beyond measure.
And for me personally, this program was an opportunity to look back and see how far we've come. When I first came to Port Hardy, Indigenous people wouldn't step foot in our library. The library's relationship with the community was tense at best, and often much worse.
Navigating this new terrain, I often felt like I was fumbling blindly. I made mistakes. I learned. I persisted. My staff and I, supported by library leadership, slowly built relationships, proving our intentions by being respectful, accessible, trustworthy, and caring. We built relationships by being allies.
6.16.2025
rotd: where freedom is concerned, do not wait for others to present it to you
Revolutionary thought of the day:
Mrs Touchet was confused. "All I intended to say was that I feel confident that the arguments I heard today, on the Downs, although at the moment only concerned with the enfranchisement of working men, will surely, in time---"
"Time!" The noun itself appeared to disgust him. "Why should I wait for what is mine by sacred right? Who can give to me what was never theirs to possess?"
"I really can't think what you mean."
"Mrs Touchet, my freedom is as fully my inheritance as it is any man's. It has no time, I need not wait for it, it was mine from the moment of my birth. Does it surprise you to hear me say so?"
"Well, for one thing you speak as if my freedom is perfect."
"I know it is not. And where freedom is concerned, Mrs Touchet, I would advise you not to wait for others to present a false gift of it to you. You will be waiting a long time. Better to 'take up arms against a sea of troubles, and by opposing, end them'."
From The Fraud, by Zadie Smith. Conversation between Bogle, a formerly enslaved Black man, and Mrs Touchet. England, 1869.
photos are posted
Photos from our recent trip to Tulsa, Kansas City, and St. Louis are now on Flickr. I'll also link each post to its album page.
My photos on Flickr are somewhat of a dump. I do delete blatant clunkers, but I don't crop or edit, and I don't spend a lot of time choosing which photos to post. It's not worth the time for my purposes. It's mainly a way to keep most of our travel photos in one place, link to wmtc, and use as a cloud backup. Meaning: the albums are large and repetitive.
Some albums, like photos from the Bob Dylan Center, are a small fraction of what we have -- yet the album is still too large and repetitive!
Photos of:
the woody guthrie center, tulsa, oklahoma
the bob dylan center, tulsa, oklahoma
red sox vs royals, kauffman stadium
gateway arch and other st. louis (includes busch stadium)
cahokia mounds state historic site (illinois)
jefferson city & tipton missouri (mennonite store)
6.13.2025
coming up for air: two thoughts on aging from george orwell
The change in his appearance after twenty years had actually frightened me. I suppose you think I mean that he looked older. But he didn't! He looked younger. And it suddenly taught me something about the passage of time.I suppose old Betterton would be about sixty-five now, so that when I last saw him he'd have been forty-five -- my age now. His hair was white now, and the day he buried Mother it was a kind of streaky grey, like a shaving-brush. And yet as soon as I saw him the first thing that struck me was that he looked younger. I'd thought of him as an old, old man, and after all he wasn't so very old. As a boy, it occurred to me, all people over forty ahd seemed to me just worn-out old wrecks, so old that there was hardly any difference between them. A man of forty-five had seemed to me older than this dodderer of sixty-five seemed now. And Christ! I was forty-five myself. It frightened me.
If I'd had a mirror I'd have looked at the whole of myself, though, as a matter of fact, I knew what I looked like already. A fat man of forty-five, in a grey herring-bone suit a bit worse for wear and a bowler hat. Wife, two kids, and a house in the suburbs written all over me. Red face and boiled blue eyes. I know, you don't have to tell me. But the thing that struck me, as I gave my dental plate the once-over before slipping it back in my mouth, was that it doesn't matter. Even false teeth don't matter. I'm fat -- yes. I look like a bookie's unsuccessful brother -- yes. No woman will ever go to bed with me again unless she's paid to. I know all that. But I tell you I don't care. I don't want the women, I don't even want to be young again. I only want to be alive. And I was alive at that moment when I stood looking at the primroses and the red embers under the hedge. It's a feeling inside you, a kind of peaceful feeling, and yet it's like a flame.
happy birthday to me: retirement update edition
I have been alive on this planet for 64 years. Didn't I just write my last "happy birthday to me" post, like, a week ago??
I looked back at my last few HBTM posts, and I do have a few updates.
Last year, in "happy birthday to me: retirement vs travel edition," I thought retirement was 10 to 12 years away. Plans have gelled since then, and I am planning to retire at age 70. I downloaded a countdown clock, now on my desktop. Today it clicked over from six years plus something to five-plus!
There are tough things about aging, for sure. Unpleasant things. There's no denying it. But there were tough things at every stage of life. Being a child is not the proverbial picnic, nor being a teenager, nor a young adult. There are always issues, always heartache, and sometimes much worse. If we're lucky, there is also love and joy, wonder and excitement, adventure and meaning.Aging is a privilege. I feel incredibly lucky and grateful to have it.
6.09.2025
what i'm reading: two by two favourite authors: part two: zadie smith's the fraud
I've read all but one of Smith's novels, and some of her nonfiction, and I plan to fill in what I've missed. She's an ambitious writer who has done a lot of different things. And like any artist who experiments with different forms, the outcomes can be uneven. (The exception to this is Colson Whitehead. How can he be so good at everything he tries??) I don't love everything Smith has written, but I love a lot of it, and for the rest, I want to come along for the ride.
In this case, for me, Smith knocks it out of the park.
Who is the fraud? (Who isn't?)
The Fraud takes place in Victorian London, and focuses on three situations.
A sensational trial is underway: the Tichborne Claimant. After the heir to the Tichborne estate (presumably) died in a shipwreck, an Australian butcher came forward claiming to be Sir Tichborne. Despite all evidence that he was a charlatan and a fraud, a sizeable chunk of the British public loved and believed him. This is the most obvious reading of the book's title.
We also meet the life and times of a minor Victorian writer, a contemporary of Dickens and Thackery, now forgotten: William Harrison Ainsworth. We see most of the action from the point of view of Ainsworth's cousin and sometime lover, Eliza Touchet. Eliza, in Victorian parlance, is a widow, forever referred to as "Mrs. Touchet". She is also an intelligent woman, with a restless hunger for knowledge, dissatisfied with the tiny box that society allows her to live in. Mrs. Touchet has hidden identities that she cannot name even to herself, as they are well outside social norms of the time.
And there is Bogle: a formerly enslaved Jamaican man, who inexplicably champions the Tichborne Claimant, and who lends gravitas and credibility to the Claimant's cause. Through Bogle, we explore the lives of generations of enslaved Africans who came to be first Jamaican, then British.
Each of these people -- the Tichborne Claimaint, Ainsworth, Mrs. Touchet, and Bogle -- are all, in some sense, frauds. The Tichborne Claimaint is perpetrating a kind of giant magic trick on the public. Ainsworth is a fraud but doesn't realize it. Mrs. Touchet lives a fraudulent life, because she has to. Bogle's motives are more obscure.
Keep reading, and you'll gain a sense that absolutely everyone is a fraud in some sense. The current Mrs. Ainsworth, who married "above her station". Charles Dickens, perhaps a fictional version of the great writer -- or perhaps a more authentic but hidden version. And on and on. Leading us to question what it would mean to live an authentic life.
The great fraud of our own times
The Fraud works on an entirely different level, too: it maps to the current political situation: the fraud who now lives in the White House.
The Tichborne case and the pro-Tichborne public echo the Orange Guy and the MAGA movement in ways that are both obvious and subtle -- and entirely clever and humorous. There are anti-vaxxers (who certainly existed back then), and outlandish conspiracy theories that contradict themselves. There is an extreme distrust of society's institutions, coupled with a blind loyalty to people of great power, incomprehensible to the intelligent and well-informed. And there is, above all, an inability to distinguish between fact and fiction. Everything about the Tichborne Claimant trial and the community -- the cult -- that formed around it can be read as current and topical.
And there's more
Many critics have written about The Fraud as a meta-novel: a novel about novelists, about Smith and her profession, and about us, the reading public. Here's a good example from The Atlantic.
It is certainly that. There are plenty of postmodern, self-referential moments that loop around themselves, where you're reading about yourself, what you are actually doing at the moment: reading a novel about a novel.
But I think the critics who read this ambitious book primarily as a meta-novel are focusing on the wrong thing. There is just so much going on.
I will include one caution: The Fraud might be a bit difficult to get into at first, as it's written in a Victorian style. Or is it a faux Victorian style? Is the style a fraud?
Give it a chance, it's worth it.
6.02.2025
what i'm watching: a complete unknown: not very profound (or kind) thoughts about this movie
Bobby, Suze, the Village, the Jacket |
Allan and I were in no rush to see it, because we love Bob Dylan, and we are well familiar with the public versions of his story.
Allan dislikes fictional biopics, and while we watched the movie last night, I remembered why I also seldom watch them. I'm actually going into my various watchlists and deleting every movie of this genre. There are at least a dozen movies like this waiting; now I've lost interest in them all.
To me, "A Complete Unknown" was like a checklist of 1961-1965 Bob Dylan. I imagined someone holding a clipboard, checking off each person and each item. Here's Alan Lomax. Here's Albert Grossman. Harold Leventhal. Tom Wilson. Woody Guthrie, Johnny Cash, Joan Baez, and Suze Rotolo (here called Sylvie). Check, check, check. There's the cap. There's the jacket. The motorcyle. Check, check, check. Folk City, the Gaslight. Walter Cronkite, the Vietnam War, the civil rights movement, the Cuban Missile Crisis. Check, check, check.
Predictably, it all leads up to the most famous incident of early Dylandom, the most-told tale, the hotly debated and revised and rewritten Dylan Goes Electric at the 1965 Newport Festival. We wondered if Mangold would repeat the legend of the ax-wielding Pete Seeger. I won't spoil it for you.
It appears that most of the casting for this movie was based on looks, which seems to be how this type of movie is made. Woman with long black hair equals Joan Baez. Heavy man equals Albert Grossman. The actor playing Baez lacked any semblance of the singer and activist's beauty and charisma, and above all, her rich, melodious voice and incredible guitar playing. Maybe that's to be expected, but it still felt like a seventh-generation photocopy.
For those who don't know this story, the film is a history lesson. For those who do, it's a hackneyed re-creation, plus a few scenes that in all likelihood did not happen. I got nothing out of it. Had I been watching alone, I would have turned it off halfway through.
For those wishing to know something about Bob Dylan, I recommend Martin Scorsese's 2005 documentary "No Direction Home". Even Scorsese's "Rolling Thunder Revue: A Bob Dylan Story" -- a fictional, somewhat surreal homage to the greatest rock tour of all time -- captured more Dylan than this movie that tried to adhere so closely to the real story.
I'm guessing this was a much better movie if you didn't know much about Dylan and don't value him as I do.
what i'm reading: two by two favourite authors: part one: roddy doyle's the women behind the door
I took a break from reading nonfiction to read novels by two of my favourite authors: The Women Behind the Door, by Roddy Doyle, and The Fraud, by Zadie Smith. I thoroughly enjoyed both of them. Here's the first.
Doyle and I go way back