8.19.2008

health care based on ideology, instead of health

Tony Clement, federal Health Minister and right-wing ideologue, is lecturing health professionals on ethics and morals, bringing his political judgements where only health decisions belong.
Health professionals who support Vancouver's safe injection site are unethical and immoral, federal Health Minister Tony Clement suggested on Monday.

"The supervised injection site undercuts the ethic of medical practice and sets a debilitating example for all physicians and nurses, both present and future in Canada," he scolded in an address to the Canadian Medical Association general council meeting in Montreal.

He called providing a safe injection site to drug addicts tantamount to offering palliative care to a patient with a treatable form of cancer.

"This is a profound moral issue, and when Canadians are fully informed of it, I believe they will reject it on principle," the minister said.

His comments come as the Conservatives have bombarded urban ridings in Vancouver and Toronto with ads, sent free using MPs' mailing privileges, that depict a discarded syringe and a headline that states: "Junkies and pushers don't belong near children and families. They should be in rehab or behind bars."

The campaign, in addition to Mr. Clement's remarks, shows the Conservatives are trying to make illegal drugs an issue that will separate them from other parties and influence key swing voters, especially women.

On Monday, Mr. Clement took issue specifically with a letter he received from CMA president Brian Day that stated: "There is growing evidence that harm-reduction efforts can have a positive effect on the poor health outcomes associated with drug use."

The minister retorted: "Is it true that supervised injections offer 'positive health outcomes?' I would not put it this way. Insite [Vancouver's safe injection site] may slow the death spiral of a deadly drug habit, but it does not reverse it. I do not regard this as a positive health outcome."

After the speech, Dr. Day said the "minister is off base in calling into question the ethics of physicians" and accused Mr. Clement of "manipulating medical ethics to make a political point."

Dr. Day noted that in a poll of Canadian physicians, 79 per cent supported harm-reduction measures, including safe injection sites.

"We have an opinion based on scientific evidence. The minister has come to a different conclusion," he said.

Carolyn Bennett, the Liberal public-health critic and a physician, was livid after the minister's speech.

"I've never seen such an offensive performance by a health minister," she said. "How dare he come to a meeting of professionals and scold them about their perceived ethical failings."

At Insite, a small facility in Vancouver's Downtown Eastside, drug users inject themselves while supervised by nurses and physicians, and receive counselling about rehabilitation.

Clean needles are provided, but drugs are not; the principal purpose is to limit the spread of infectious diseases. Insite was granted an exemption from federal drug laws in 2003 so its users cannot be prosecuted for drug possession.

The Conservative government has vowed to close Insite, but the facility won a reprieve this spring when the B.C. Supreme Court struck down parts of Canada's drug laws. Ottawa has appealed.

For the facts and news about Insite, see Keep Insite Open, written by Jen, a wmtc reader and commenter, who is also a friend of the War Resisters Support Campaign.

5 comments:

Jen said...

'kay, I haven't made it past the second paragraph yet...

Criticism #1: Cancer patients with treatable forms of cancer DO get palliative care. The guy keeps using that analogy and it's just plain wrong.

Kim_in_TO said...

"I've never seen such an offensive performance by a health minister,"

Nor have I. I'm trying to find words for Clement right now - something that could be used in front of children. I'm not having any luck.

Gazetteer said...

They see this as a classic fear-driven wedge issue.....When swing readers read 'insite' they want them to see marauding junkies, pushers, killers and thugs selling kids dimebags by the dozen in gym class.

If it was purely ideological I'd actually have more respect for them.....


_____
(but not much more)

.

Wrye said...

I live in the Vancouver area and am regularly recieving "Free" mailings from Conservative MPs in Alberta and Ontario.

So to sum up, your tax dollars spent by your MPs, to hassle people in other ridings on the other side of the country.

L-girl said...

Gazetteer: good point. But fear is the right wing's stock in trade. It goes hand in hand with the ideology.

Wrye: ugh.